Continued Respiratory Therapy Phone: 866-382-0799


How Can I Elicit Change Talk in a Patient?

Michael Hoffman, PhD

June 1, 2021

Share:

Question

How can I elicit change talk in a patient?

Answer

Let's discuss some of the ways that we might engage a patient in change talk. Behavior change is not just education; it is actually motivation and willingness to engage in change.

Eliciting change talk is one way to engage someone to change their behaviors. The "Motivational interviewing" by William R. Miller and Stephen Rollnick is a great resource. I recommend you read it - you don't need to be a psychologist or a therapist to benefit from the information.

In the book is an idea to ask a patient to rate themselves where they are, on a scale of one to 10. We think that most patients have some sort of ambivalence about behavior change. They may not be 100% on board with change or against it, and maybe they can articulate and explain a couple of reasons why they might go either way.

For example, say a patient needs to undergo a certain procedure, and they're resistant towards it. I can use scaling by saying, "If 1 = I will never have that procedure, absolutely not, and a 10 = Yes, I want that procedure right now, where are you on that scale?" The patient's answer will give you a sense of where that patient is with their decision. They may tell you that they're at 3, and say something like, "You know I really don't want to move forward with this new surgery, I'm at 3." I can then pause, and ask some questions. I can ask them why they are at 3 and not at 1. If I say something like that, then the patient or caregiver can explain and detail the reasons why they're not lower. In other words, they have to argue for the change (from 1 to 3). True behavior change comes from increasing motivation and getting a patient themselves, talking about the reason of why they want to engage in a change. If they say, "Well I'm a 3 and not a 1 because I know this would probably be really helpful for me, and make my breathing easier most likely." Now you're getting that patient discussing reasons for change.

You can also get them to discuss reasons for change by asking them, "What makes you think you need to change?" With teens, one of my favorite questions to ask is "Why do you think your caregiver wants you to do this? What do you think they would say if we asked them?" Again, it gets the person talking about the reasons for change. Then you can ask if they agree with the caregiver. 

You can also ask what the patient thinks will happen if they don't change. Ask them what would happen if they don't go through with the procedure. They may list things like they could be re-admitted, or might not be discharged.  Get the patient to talk about the reasons that they do not want to maintain their current challenges.

Another question you can ask to elicit change behavior is, "Do you think others are concerned about your behaviors, and why?" I use the example of caregivers, but it could really be anyone.

Finally, you could have this conversation from the other direction. If the patient says they are a 3, ask what it would take to move them to a 7, for example. Ask what barriers there are to move them to a 7 and what you can do to help them. This gets them talking about what else needs to happen or what else needs to change to get their motivation to increase over time.

This has been a quick recap of motivational interviewing and change talk, but it's definitely worthwhile to think about and read about. The whole idea is to get on the side of your patient, roll with the resistance, and get them talking more about the reasons that they want to engage in a change, rather than not.  

This Ask the Expert is an edited excerpt from the course, Therapeutic Strategies for Counseling Complex Patients within a Pediatric Critical Care Settingpresented by Michael Hoffman, PhD.


michael hoffman

Michael Hoffman, PhD

Dr. Michael Hoffman is an Assistant Professor of Pediatrics at Thomas Jefferson University, Sidney Kimmel Medical College, and Pediatric Psychologist at Nemours/AI duPont Hospital for Children with a specialization in working with children with chronic medical conditions and their families. Dr. Hoffman completed his Ph.D. through the University of Miami Clinical Psychology program and his pediatric psychology residency and fellowship through Nemours/AI duPont Hospital for Children. His research and clinical work have centered on integrating psychological services into multidisciplinary clinics, including the cardiac intensive care unit, audiology, ENT, and cleft palate/craniofacial services, to improve quality of life in children and adolescents with medical complexity.  


Related Courses

Therapeutic Strategies for Counseling Complex Patients within a Pediatric Critical Care Setting
Presented by Michael Hoffman, PhD
Video

Presenter

Michael Hoffman, PhD
Course: #1006Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'He made some very helpful points'   Read Reviews
This course will review concrete, specific therapeutic strategies for managing complex patients and their families who present within a critical care setting. This may include patients who are non-adherent to medical recommendations, have significant medical complexity, and/or other multicultural/diversity issues.

Palliative Care and the Respiratory Therapist
Presented by Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Video

Presenter

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Course: #1969Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very educational'   Read Reviews
This course explores the ethical considerations and the fundamental distinctions between palliative care and hospice, providing respiratory therapists with a comprehensive understanding of these approaches to patient care. Additionally, it delves into the application of palliative care principles within the context of chronic lung disease while also emphasizing the crucial role that respiratory therapists play in delivering compassionate and holistic palliative care to patients.

Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Anxiety: What is the Connection?
Presented by Kelvin Imo, DDS, IAOS-Diplomate Candidate
Video

Presenter

Kelvin Imo, DDS, IAOS-Diplomate Candidate
Course: #1536Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'none at this time'   Read Reviews
Evidence in current research suggests sleep apnea and anxiety are connected, creating ongoing consequences for an individual's quality of life if left untreated. The course discusses the interrelationship between the two disorders and the recognition of high-risk groups for practitioners providing care.

Mechanical Ventilation: Weaning Process
Presented by Duane Reed, EdD, RRT, RCP
Video

Presenter

Duane Reed, EdD, RRT, RCP
Course: #1541Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'it was made simple to understand compressing everything to 1 hour '   Read Reviews
The course introduces the practitioner to criteria and procedures for standard weaning in mechanical ventilation. The course discusses indicators used to predict weaning success and failure in mechanical ventilation.

Understanding the ROX Index: When is HFNC Enough?
Presented by Jessica Fino, EdD, RRT
Live WebinarTue, Dec 3, 2024 at 3:00 pm EST
Tue, Dec 3, 2024 at 3:00 pm EST

Presenter

Jessica Fino, EdD, RRT
Course: #2057Level: Introductory1 Hour
This course provides a review of the ROX Index as a tool for high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) use. In addition, this course discusses current research relating to the success and failure of HFNC when comparing ROX scores across patient populations.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.