Question
How do individual and systemic factors influence the impact of school crises on those involved?
Answer
The impact of a school crisis is shaped by both systemic and individual factors. Schools function as interconnected systems, meaning any disruption to one part of the system affects the entire system. This systemic lens helps us understand that crises reverberate through every level of the school community, influencing students, staff, and families alike.
On an individual level, the effects of a crisis depend on personal experiences, resilience, and proximity to the event. Factors such as prior trauma history, coping mechanisms, and access to social support play significant roles. For instance, individuals with unresolved trauma may be more vulnerable to developing crisis-related psychological challenges. Conversely, those with strong support networks, mindfulness practices, or other coping strategies are often better equipped to process and recover from the emotional impact.
Proximity to the crisis also shapes its effect, with a stronger "dose-response relationship" noted in those more closely connected to the event. Those directly involved, such as whistleblowers, first responders, or individuals with personal ties to victims, often experience more acute symptoms. Additionally, social inclusion serves as a protective factor, with youth who feel supported by peers generally faring better than those who experience social exclusion. These nuanced layers underscore the importance of both individual and systemic perspectives in addressing the aftermath of school crises.
This Ask the Expert is an edited excerpt from the course, Anticipating, Preparing, and Responding to School Crises, presented by Stephanie Carnes, PhD, MSW LCSW, LL.M
